hello,

how to get better regen with fmrte or pre game editor?

I always use the power regen file but it doesn't solve much.

even changing youth rating (even youth facilities etc) and attributes templetas doesn't solve much also because there are no attributes like consistency and important match.

and touch the youth rating of all the nations never get you a balanced situation but the main problem is that certain prototypes of players never or almost never come out, for example:

• players over 190 cm

• central defenders over 190 cm and with a good concentration

• goalkeepers are often short and/or don't have jumping, just as they don't have anticipation

• complete full-backs, tall ones are even rarer

• complete midfielders, tall ones are even rarer

• tall and complete strikers

can't something be done to act on the creation of regen?

or to make mass edits but random? i can't put the same values of PA or consistency or important match or professionalism etc to everyone

for example it would be nice to be able to do as in the wonderkid generator of fmrte and modify which are the special, additional and normal attributes for each position

or anyway do you have various suggestions on what to touch in the editor or with fmrte to improve the situation? or how to do a random mass edit?

thanks

Hi

I will tag @PODSY12345 as I seem to remember he was running experiments on this in previous versions of the game,

he will have some tips

what game version are you using?

you can set up minus values in the various attributes fields of a player in pre game editor[it then generates random numbers between set parameters]

so it may be possible to do this in the wonderkid generator in fmrte, its something you could try out

Here are the options for minus ranges in pre game editor

7 hours ago, culturedleftfoot said:

Here are the options for minus ranges in pre game editor

what page of the pre game editor is this?

i am playing FM18 but i think it’s always the same

however I do not want to modify current players, present in the database.

but change the basic settings that determine the generation of regens in the future

or on fmrte do a mass edit, for example, of the young players but randomic,

unfortunately putting PA -4 in the mass edit does not seem to have any effect and in any case this would not solve the problem of players always created with the same problems (short goalkeepers without jumping and anticipation; not complete full-backs; few players with consistency, important match, professionalism; shorts players etc).

and this does not only apply to wonderkids but to all regens, even those with 130-140-150 PA, they are never well balanced in their characteristics and after decades in the game certain profiles are untraceable and the only solution is to train the wonderkids with 190-200 PA by forcing their growth where they are lacking (but this therefore only applies if you train a top club)

I do not think there are any options to do this.

in the pre game editor I saw that in the nations there are tactical preferences, preferred formations etc but even this does not seem to change much, I tried to put formations with WB to many nations but always the complete WB are practically non-existent.

I do not know if there can be a better way to change youth rating and other settings, I do not know, any advice would be good

Hi

that is the player profile in PGE you can set any attribute to a - value

what you want to do isnt possible IMO

but wait for Podsy to reply he will have some pointers to help

cheers

I will keep this thread here even though you are not using FMRTE24 [it should be in archive] but it is basically the same across all versions of the App regarding this

14 hours ago, culturedleftfoot said:

I will keep this thread here even though you are not using FMRTE24 [it should be in archive] but it is basically the same across all versions of the App regarding this

what you want to do isnt possible IMO

but wait for Podsy to reply he will have some pointers to help

cheers

thanks, yes it's the same for all versiones.

i'll wait, I don't know how to change future regens (and not current players, if not with a mass edit of the u18 but random and managing to create a balance of the attributes)

Hi Ciaoragazzi,

I'd love to be able to help but you've done far more work than I did with, it seems, the same amount of success I had - none.

I resorted to manual edits/re-balances, as no matter what I tried in the PGE or in FMRTE regens were unblanced and unrealistic.

Sorry - I spent ages on it, and just gave up!

Hope someone else can help!

10 minutes ago, PODSY12345 said:

Hi Ciaoragazzi,

I'd love to be able to help but you've done far more work than I did with, it seems, the same amount of success I had - none.

I resorted to manual edits/re-balances, as no matter what I tried in the PGE or in FMRTE regens were unblanced and unrealistic.

Sorry - I spent ages on it, and just gave up!

Hope someone else can help!

Thanks for the input mate

sometimes we can spend hours/days on projects only to find it has little effect in the game

I came to the conclusion many years ago the game/Pre game editor isnt that great

the correlation between changing things in the SI pre game editor and how that bears out in the game is poor,

it isnt functioning as good as it could/should be it isnt a priority for them

I dread to think what the new PGE version will be like🙃